We Buy Comics & Collectibles | Long Street Comics

We Buy Comics, Cards & Collectibles

Looking to sell your comic collection, MTG card collection, or graded sports cards? Long Street Comics buys collections of all sizes — from single key issues to full runs, from bulk lots to high-grade slabs.

Note: we are by appointment only while we finish the remodel. Call (606) 312-7952 or email store@longstreetcomics.com and we will set a time.

What We Buy

  • Comic Books — Back issues, key issues, full runs, Golden Age, Silver Age, Bronze Age, Modern Age. We buy single books and entire collections.
  • Magic: The Gathering Singles & Collections — Reserved List, Commander staples, sealed product. Looking to sell your MTG cards near me? We make it easy.
  • Graded Cards & Raw Sports Cards — PSA, BGS, SGC graded cards, vintage baseball, football, basketball cards, and unopened packs.
  • Pokémon Cards — Vintage Base Set, first editions, holographic rares, sealed booster boxes and packs.
  • Other Collectibles — Action figures, statues, original comic art, gaming memorabilia, and more.

How It Works

  1. Contact Us — Email us at store@longstreetcomics.com or call (606) 312-7952 with a description or photos of your collection.
  2. Get an Appraisal — We offer free, no-obligation comic collection appraisals. Book a time to bring your collection in, or we can review photos remotely for large lots.
  3. Get Paid — We pay fair market value in cash or store credit (store credit gets you more). Same-day offers on most collections.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I sell my comics to Long Street Comics?

The easiest way is to contact us first — send an email with photos or a list of what you have. We are by appointment only while we finish the remodel, so call or email and we will schedule a time that works, for a small lot or a full collection.

How do you price comic collections?

We use current market data — recent eBay sold listings, CGC census, and GoCollect — to price accurately. We look at condition, key issue status, and current demand. We want to give you a fair offer so you feel good about the deal.

Do you buy damaged or reading-copy comics?

Yes. While high-grade copies get premium offers, we also buy lower-grade reading copies, especially for key issues and hard-to-find back issues. Fill out our contact form and let us know what you have.

Do you buy MTG cards near me in Kentucky?

Yes — we are located at 408 N Long St, London, KY 40741 and we actively buy Magic: The Gathering cards. Whether you have a binder of singles, a full Commander collection, or sealed booster boxes, contact us first and we will set a time to look them over.

Can I trade instead of sell?

Absolutely. Trade credit is always an option and often gets you more value than cash. We are a buy-sell-trade shop at heart.

Long Street Comics is located at 408 N Long St, London, KY 40741. Call us at (606) 312-7952 or email store@longstreetcomics.com to start the process today.

Instant offers

Get an instant offer on your Magic cards

We price each card by printing, condition and finish. Store credit pays more than cash.

Sell or trade

Tell us what you have

Send us the basics and we'll reply with next steps, usually within a day. No obligation.

What are you selling?
Paste a list, card names, cert numbers, key issues, or just describe it. Rough is fine.
Google Photos, Drive, Dropbox or iCloud link. Or just reply to our email with photos.

We're by appointment only while we finish the remodel. Prefer to talk? Call (606) 312-7952.